While playing basketball with friends, two young residents got into a physical altercation. Buffalo Police arrived on the scene to break it up, and one of the young men informed the cops that there was no need to intervene. “We fight every day and we would be friends the next day,” explained the young man. Despite his attempts to de-escalate what he believed to be a non-threatening situation, the police soon spiraled out of control.

Two police quickly multiplied to thirty as residents gathered around the unfolding scene. At one point, an officer even drove his motorcycle through the crowd of boys as the remaining police ordered the by-standers to return to their homes. Irate that the reckless officer had hit their sons, two mothers and a reverend approached the officers. They had underestimated the hostility of the police.

An attempt to address one incident of violence instigated even more physical abuse as the officers lashed out at the residents who dared to confront them. According to community members, “Two more Police officers came and they tried to arrest Rev. Bryant, pulled a gun on him, hit one of the mothers in the head, and then again the Precinct #10 cops came, riot ready—pulling their guns out, swinging their sticks at us and telling us to go home.”

Community Response

After the Police Violence that community experienced, community members initially went home and waited until about midnight until folks went out with the intention of causing property damage. There may not have appeared to be much damage on the first night, however the visceral reaction to over policing and brutality in the Lakeview Project was not confined to the West Side of Buffalo.

The chaos spread like wildfire onto the East Side where most of the Black population resided. The very next night after Molotov cocktails exploded on the West Side, the Buffalo Evening News reported that the East Side convulsed under the weight of vandalism, fires, and looting. On Tuesday June 27th, eight people were reported injured, nine fires were set ablaze, and an estimated twenty-three people were arrested.

According to some, Mayor Sedita was partially responsible for the disturbances that were taking place because of joblessness, poor housing, and a lack of recreational facilities. “The power structure in Buffalo has contributed as much as any other factor to the disturbance in the past three nights by their indifference to the needs of all its citizens,” remarked Rev. Milton A. Williams, the President of the NAACP Buffalo Chapter. He railed against: “…the retailers who have refused over the years to hire Negroes in numbers comparable to the number of Negroes in the community…A mayor who permits his departments to operate recreational areas in a most deplorable condition which mirrors the contempt of the white community for this area…A Board of Education and the head of our School Department who claim insight and concern for the poor area schools but who failed to provide $50,000 for the operation of the public school playgrounds in a $51 Million budget.”

The Democratic Nominating Convention opened September 7th, 1966 at Memorial Auditorium, in downtown Buffalo. Vice President Humphrey arrived the following morning. His visit was protested by Youth Against War and Fascism. As the anti-war demonstrators silently picketed Memorial Auditorium, two participants, Victor Aronow and Jeanette Merrill, were arrested. They complied peacefully and were taken to police headquarters.

Reform Democrat delegates from New York City who witnessed the arrests approached permanent convention chairman Percy Sutton at the noon recess and threatened to raise the issue on the convention floor. They argued that the public was invited by all delegates to the convention and the arrests were a violation of this invitation.

Mayor Sedita, then still hopeful of the nomination for lieutenant governor, acted quickly to prevent the threatened action. Mayor Sedita apologized personally to the demonstrators and called a special city court session to dismiss the charges.

Mrs. Merrill, charged with resisting arrest, refusing to comply with the reasonable request of an officer and using profanity, stated: “I was not guilty of anything I was arrested for, as is the case with all anti-war demonstrators . . . this is not an isolated incident. I was the victim today. They are carrying out a policy from above which is political in character."

Buffalo Police officer Edward B. Wisniewski Jr of Fillmore Station. shot Stevenson McDuffie, a 16 year old Black boy, as he ran from a patrol car. He was shot in the upper right thigh and left shoulder. According to Officer Wisniewski and his partner, Officer Edmund Dukat, they were responding to a reported theft of a purse which contained $2.

Outcome

Two felony charges were placed against 16 year old Stevenson McDuffie—second degree grand larceny and attempted escape. McDuffie pled Not Guilty to the charges in his hospital room. City Judge Joseph Mattina, who went to the hospital for the arraignment set bail at $1,000.

Officer Wisniewski was put on temporary leave and was exonerated by Commissioner Felicetta of any wrongdoing. Felicetta turned his findings over to District Attorney Michael Dillion for presentation to a grand jury.

Community Response

Civil rights leaders and leaders representing CORE and NAACP demanded the suspension of Officer Wisniewski, called for a public hearing of the case, and criticized the handling of the case by Mayor Frank Sedita and Police Commissioner Frank Felicetta.

Donald R Lee, president of the NAACP, said the police department's investigation of the August 3 shooting "completely shocked the organization by its obvious attempt to whitewash the shooting." Samuel L Green, counsel for CORE, described the case as "police brutality" and charged that Felicetta's "private investigation" did not answer why the officer "had to shot McDuffie." Green said that Felicetta did not call for testimony of citizens who may have been witnesses to the shooting. David Collins, president of the Neighborhood(Ellicott) Advisory Council, Community Action Organization, said: "I feel if we don't take a stand on this, it will be the same thing over and over again." One leader urged that the incident be settled promptly before, "a powder keg explodes." The leaders approved a letter which was sent to Gov. Rockefeller asking him to investigate the case and authorized civil rights leaders to schedule picketing of City Hall to demonstrate their protest of the McDuffie case.

On Saturday, January 8, Vice President Hubert Humphrey visited Buffalo and during his stay spoke at a banquet at the Statler Hilton commemorating one thousand years of Christianity in Poland. His presence in Buffalo prompted local peace groups, under the sponsorship of the Buffalo Youth Against War and Fascism, to hold a demonstration in front of the hotel aimed at highlighting their opposition to the war in Viet Nam and particularly their opposition to certain public statements Vice President Humphrey had made in connection with the war.

The demonstration had been in progress for over an hour when four of the demonstrators left the line and entered the hotel "just to warm up.” Daniel Katz, one of the four who went to warm up, was approached by Buffalo Detective Joseph A. Schwartz and was told to leave. A scuffle and ensued and Katz was arrested for "refusing to accede to the reasonable request of an officer."

Katz later complained of rough treatment at the hands of please, both in the hotel and on the way to the station, and stated that Schwartz, who is in plain clothes, never identified himself as an officer and that Katz had never been informed that he was under arrest.

Katz was charged with disorderly conduct and attempting to enter the elevator in which Vice President Humphrey was riding. The judge on the case later dismissed the later charge on the basis of contradictory testimony of the prosecution witness. However, the judge refused the motion by a defense attorney Richard Lipsitz for dismissal on the grounds of conflicting prosecution testimony.

When asked his reaction after the trial, Katz stated, "I feel that the actions of the arresting officers were an intimidations of the peace movement, the civil rights movement, and any other movement which actively dissents from the status quo."

Katz was convicted on January 27 and fined $25.

Buffalo Police arrested 34 in a brutal raid in the William-Pine, East Ferry-Michigan area on the evening on September 11, 1954 in the largest anti-Black attack in years. The roundup was ordered by Commissioner Noeppel, allegedly because of complaints that loungers refused to break up and let pedestrians pass.

Eight of those arrested were youths from 16 to 19 years old. In court they were told by the tough-talking judge that now they would have a police record, which would go on their army service record or disqualify them for civil service jobs.

Among the police victims was a Black minister, Rev. Leroy Anderson, pastor of the Church of God in Christ, Lackawanna, and member of the Lackawanna City Planning Commission. Mr. Anderson, describing the high-handed Buffalo police methods, vile language, and brutality, said he planned to sue the city for false arrest. Mr. Anderson was about to enter a store when he was ordered into a patrol wagon with, "Come on, you go too, you bastard!" When he protested at the language, he was told, "When I get you to Number Six (the police station) I'll do more than that to you." He heard one of the other men arrested on the corner cry out when a policeman struck him.

Most of the other people reported similar treatment. The police hauled in about four loads, grabbing them at random off the street. One man was picked up as he got out of his car to ask a policeman what was wrong. Another was arrested on his way to work.

At the station, a cop told the people, "Just shut your mouth. If you're quiet, you won't get in trouble."

Outcome

The judge was just as vicious as were the commissioner and the police. He denied the Rev. Anderson the right to provide his own bail, committing him to a cell for the night along with the others who were arrested. The judge calling the people before him "bums," he told them that because of their conduct it was not safe for "respectable citizens” and "daughters" to walk down the street.

At the time of the arrests, aroused people formed until the crowd reached some 300. News of the police outrage spread quickly through the city and protests were heard in the Black churches the next day.

In the morning of Oct. 10. 1953 two young workers, Norman and James Daniels, were unmerciful beat of by six club-happy Buffalo Police Officers . . . a beating which continued in two police vehicles en route to the jail. Both men were hospitalized with severe injuries.

42 members of the Communist Party of Buffalo had been arrested by Buffalo Police, Mrs. Dr. Anna Reinstein, wife of Boris Reinstein, being the last victim. Mrs. Reinstein and 10 others were released on bail.

Frank M. Cassidy was ordered released by Justice Charles B. Sears on the ground that the information against him was not properly drawn up. But as Cassidy left the court he was rearrested on new information drawn by Walter P. Hofheins, of the District Attorney’s office.

The new information alleged that Cassidy “is feloniously and a member of a certain unlawful society commonly known as the Communist Party, organized and existing for the purpose of teaching and advocating the doctrine of criminal anarchy and among other things, the overthrown of organized government by force and violence.”