Incidents (137 documented)

    Incident 270

    Date Jul 29, 2014
    Time 06:00 AM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Shawn D. Adams , Joseph M. Cook , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    On July 29 2014, Buffalo Narcotics officers and the SWAT team stormed a West Seneca residence on Edson Street at 6 am in the morning. The residents were sleeping with their house-dog, a nine month old pit-bull puppy named Rocky, who was beloved both in the house and within the community. Rocky had been trained and loved from the time of his birth, was very well socialized, and did not have a mean bone in his body.

    In fact, medical records show that despite the officers frightening method of entry into the residence, all Rocky did was stretch his legs at the foot of Joseph Smith, one of his owners' bed. Photos, police reports, and medical records show that two narcotics officers Detectives Joseph Cook and Shawn Adams shot Rocky numerous times with multiple firearms from over 10 feet away as the innocent dog stretched on Smith's bed.

    Outcome

    The police found a small amount of drug residue and marijuana in the cubbies of a bedroom and charged Joseph Smith, whose dog was blown up at his feet. Smith’s attorney, after a long legal battle, was able to get the charges against his client dismissed. Despite the thousands of dollars that have gone into this worthless prosecution, the DA doubled downed to protect the dog killers and refilled the charges against Smith.

    A civil suit was filed by the three residents against City of Buffalo, Daniel Derenda, Joe Cook, Kenneth Morano, and Shawn Adams for damages. The lawsuits were settled for a collective amount of $65,002.

    Address Edson Street
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 253

    Date May 11, 2014
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Adam E. O'shei , Robert Eloff , Michael Beavers , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Air National Guardsman William C. Sager Jr. was gravely injured when he was pushed down a flight of stairs by Molly's Pub bar manager Jeffrey Basil. When the incident happened at Molly's, two off-duty Buffalo Police officers were there -- Adam O'Shei and Robert Eloff. Officer Eloff helped drag the unconscious Sager out of the bar after the push and handcuffed him at Basil’s request. After spending weeks in a coma at the hospital, Sager died. He was 28.

    The incident occurred during a sad chapter of Buffalo history during which members of the Buffalo Police force were not only allowed to have side jobs working security for the local bars, but they were actually encouraged to do so. Despite knowing that this system created a "breakdown in the chain of command," the City's Police Commissioner felt that having visible police stationed throughout the city's bars provided an added police presence at no cost to the taxpayers.

    This policy decision was longstanding, and had produced a plethora of citizen complaints from bar patrons. The practice created a conflict of interest for the off duty police, who developed an allegiance to personnel at the bars they were supposed to be policing. The result was a long list of complaints, including underage drinking, bouncers getting away with being overly aggressive, and in some cases, the off-duty police themselves using excessive force. Although the Police Commissioner acknowledged that he considered ending the program prior to May 11,2014' that suggestion was opposed by the rank and file as well as the police union, and the policy was therefore allowed to continue. After the death of William Sager, the Commissioner terminated the policy. However, the practice of off-duty Buffalo Police Officers being allowed to work security jobs on the side continues to this day.

    Outcome

    Officer O'Shei was suspended for his involvement in the Molly's Pub incident that led to the death of a national guardsman but did not face any charges. Eloff pled guilty to violating the civil rights of Donald Hall, a friend of Sager. He resigned from the force as part of the plea. Eloff was sentenced to three months in federal prison and three months of home confinement in 2016 in connection to the incident.

    In 2015, William Sager Sr., the father of William Sager Jr, filed a civil suit for damages against the City of Buffalo, the Buffalo Police Department, the Buffalo Police Benevolent Association, Buffalo Police Commissioner Daniel Derenda, Buffalo Police Officer Robert Eloff, Buffalo Police Officer Adam O'Shei, Jeffrey Basil, Molly's Pub, the shareholders of Molly's Pub, and Independent Health. The Buffalo Common Council approved a $3.3 million settlement ten years later.

    Erika Webster, William Sager Jr.’s fiancé said, "this resolution doesn't change what happened to Bill, but I feel that with this, the Buffalo Police Department understands and acknowledges their role in what transpired at that bar all those years ago. I am grateful to the City of Buffalo for the policy changes they have implemented since Bill's assault. I hope that they have prevented additional tragedies so that his death was not in vain. Bill lived his life with great meaning and purpose and all we wanted was to ensure that meaning was extended beyond his premature loss of life."

    In 2015, a friend of William Sager also filed a civil suit for damages against the City of Buffalo, the Buffalo Police Department, Buffalo Police Officer Robert Eloff, Buffalo Police Officer Michael Beavers, Molly's Pub, and the shareholders of Molly's Pub. The council approved a $290,000 settlement for this lawsuit.

    Address Main Street
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 325

    Date May 03, 2014
    Time 04:30 PM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers William(Craig) C. Macy Jr
    Description

    On May 3, 2014 at around 4:30 P.M., Buffalo Police Housing Unit Officer Craig Macy was conducting a “vertical foot patrol” at 305 Perry Sweep in response to “general resident complaints” when he saw Raymon Richardson exit an elevator in the building. Without having any reason to suspect Mr. Richardson of trespass or wrongdoing, Macy approached Mr. Richardson and asked him whether he lived in the housing project. Mr. Richardson informed Macy that he did not live there.

    Macy continued to press Mr. Richardson with further questions, but Mr. Richardson replied by stating that he would not respond because “this was harassment.” At that point, Macy informed Mr. Richardson that because he said that he did not live there, he was no longer free to leave and arrested him and took him into custody at the BPD Housing Unit headquarters.

    After an hour, Mr. Richardson informed the officers that his children may be home alone. Buffalo police officers then accompanied Mr. Richardson to his home, saw that his two children were indeed alone, and subsequently charged him with Endangering the Welfare of a Child and two counts of Trespass.

    Outcome

    During criminal proceedings, the Judge dismissed Mr. Richardson’s charges on the basis that Buffalo Police Officer Craig Macy violated Mr. Richardson’s Fourth Amendment rights. Although the court found that Macy’s initial inquiry was constitutional, Judge Martoche found his secondary more accusatory questioning and subsequent detention was unconstitutional because Mr. Richardson’s conduct did not present the “individualized” circumstances necessary to show “that criminal activity was afoot.”

    The Judge found that the fact that Mr. Richardson did not live in the high rise and that he decided to stop answering Macy’s questions was insufficient for an investigatory detention and arrest. In dismissing the charges based on Buffalo police department’s illegally obtained evidence, the court underscored “the fact that an encounter occuring in a high crime vicinity, without more, has not passed De Bour and Hollman scrutiny” for even the lowest-level of inquiry. The Court made clear that “simply put, police encounters with civilian subjects must be proportionate to the concerns raised by the subject’s observed conduct.”

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 31

    Date Apr 19, 2014
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Nicholas A. Militello , Jeffrey Rinaldo , John Cirulli , Dennis R. Gilbert , Brian Griffin , Lindsay A. Laracuente-Zgoda , Daniel Derenda , Lamar M. Mcculley
    Description

    CW: On the night of April 19th, when John Willet, a 22 year old Black man, was driving, he noticed a car was following him. Fearing that it may be someone meaning to do him harm, he sped away. The car following him turned out to be undercover police car, which pursued Willet to Ontario and Philadelphia Streets. Willet parked his vehicle, got out and ran across the street where he willingly surrendered. Willet reported that he stood there with his hands in the air when a Buffalo Police Officer punched him and threw him down to the ground. Buffalo Police Officer John Cirulli and Nicholas Militello along with four other officers kneed and punched Willet while trying to apprehend him. John Cirulli kicked and punched Willet while he was handcuffed and laying face down, pleading for them to stop.

    Outcome

    On April 28, 2014, officers were placed on administrative leave. On April 29, 2014, BPD suspended John Cirulli from duty without pay for violating departmental rules and regulations. On May 29, 2014, he resigned his position with the Buffalo Police Department and pleaded guilty to two federal misdemeanor civil rights violations. He was sentenced to 12 months probation.

    On April 15, 2015, Willet filed a lawsuit against him, Militello, the Buffalo Police Department, the city of Buffalo, Jeffrey Rinaldo and another defendant. Judge Richard J. Arcara dismissed the case.

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 234

    Date Nov 21, 2013
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Joseph R. Hassett , Corey R. Krug , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Police officers Corey Krug and Joseph Hassett assaulted and detained Rickey Spencer for a violation of NYS V&T Law 1236 Lamps and Other Equipment on Bicycles in that he did not have a light or reflector on his bicycle. Spencer required surgery on his arm due to the assault.

    Outcome

    A civil case against the City of Buffalo, Corey Krug, and Joseph Hassett was settled for $115,000. There has been no information released about disciplinary action against officer Krug or Hassett for this incident of brutality and the $115,000 that he cost Buffalo tax payers.

    Address E. Ferry Street
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 242

    Date Jun 03, 2013
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Joseph M. Cook , John C. Garcia , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Police busted down a door of a Breckenridge apartment belonging to Iraqi War combat veteran, Sgt. Adam Arroyo in Buffalo looking for drugs. In the process, the police shot Arroyo's dog Cindy multiple times, killing the dog.

    Police claim they read his address wrong. They meant to raid the upstairs front apartment at 304 Breckenridge St, but they became confused and raided the rear apartment. Busting down Arroyo’s door, they found that he was not at home. His dog Cindy, a pit bull, was tethered to the sink in the kitchen.

    Detective Joseph Cook, accompanied by a SWAT team of police, chose to stand beyond the length of tether and shoot Cindy, as opposed to wasting the time it would take to get animal control into the house and place the dog in a kennel.

    After Cindy was shot, animal control arrived and unloosened her from her bloodied leash. The impact of the bullet had thrown the dog, and it had become entangled around her neck. They were inconvenienced as they unwound her leash and untethered her, removing her carcass in a body bag.

    Without realizing it was not the apartment named on the search warrant, police were inconvenienced as they ransacked the apartment. Blood from the dog got on their boots and, despite wiping it off on the carpet, they spread it all over the apartment. Some of it stuck like plague to their boots.

    Address Breckenridge
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 330

    Date Dec 06, 2012
    Time 04:45 PM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Kenneth Agee Jr , Jared M. Domaracki , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Issac Parker's sport utility vehicle was pulled over by Buffalo police officers Kenneth Agee and Jared Domaracki on December 6th, 2012 for a faulty headlight. Officer Agee and his partner, Domaracki, suspected Parker was intoxicated. According to police, Domaracki reached in through the driver's side window to turn off the ignition, and Parker allegedly hit the accelerator and took off down Fillmore. Agee shot Parker once in the right side, kiilling him. Parker continued on Fillmore before crashing into three street light poles, one of which fell on Ida Murphy, killing her.

    A wrongful death lawsuit was filed by the Estate of Ida Murphy and was settled for $125,000. A wrongful death lawsuit was filed by the Estate of Issac Parker and was settled for $50,000.

    Address Riley Street near Fillmore Avenue
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 26

    Date Nov 28, 2012
    Time 08:54 PM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Michael J. Anderson , Robert M. States , Matthew Cross , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    In 2012, Richard A. Metcalf Jr. died from strangulation when jail guards at the Erie County Holding Center secured a spit mask around his neck, leading to suffocation while he was restrained and left face down on a stretcher with the mask and a pillowcase covering his head. Metcalf, aged 35, was transported to Erie County Medical Center and taken off life support after two days.

    Outcome

    In a civil suit filed by Metcalf’s father, Erie County could have settled over the death of Richard A. Metcalf Jr. for $17 million, but instead took the case to a trial. The trial ended with a jury’s $95 million judgment against the county – the largest known civil verdict ever against the county. Before the lawsuit filed by Metcalf’s father went to trial, the county had already spent $900,000 on legal bills related to the case. Toth said he expects legal costs for defending the county through the trial to total around $2 million.

    County Attorney Jeremy Toth called the jury’s decision “inexplicable” and the county would argue the court for a reduced settlement. After arguing for a reduced settlement, a state judge has cut the damages award for the murder of Richard A. Metcalf Jr. from $100 million to $20 million. Acting State Supreme Court Justice Mark J. Grisanti reduced the jury's April award after attorneys for the county and five current and former jail deputies argued that what the jury granted was "excessive."

    The jury determined the five deputies used excessive force and four of the five were negligent and violated Metcalf’s civil rights by being “deliberately indifferent” to his medical needs. Jurors in the Metcalf case found that the county and five current and former deputies were liable for using excessive force and depriving Metcalf of proper mental and physical medical care. Among the former deputies that were found to have used used excessive force on Metcalf were Matthew Cross and Robert States, who are now current Buffalo Police Officers. Robert Dee was fired in 2022 by the Sheriff’s Office after a series of investigations into unrelated misconduct, including domestic violence charges and improper contact with a woman who was incarcerated. Edward Kawalek and Scott Emerling still work for the Sheriff’s Office.

    Address Delaware Ave
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 230

    Date Sep 17, 2012
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Joseph R. Hassett , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Officer Joseph Hassett maliciously and intentionally assaulted Adam Hamideh without provocation during a September 2012 arrest near 1425 Clinton St.

    Hamideh said he was he was painfully and seriously injured from the repeated blows and also suffered a shock to his nerves and nervous system and may have permanent defects.

    Outcome

    A civil case against the City of Buffalo was settled for $70,000. There has been no information released about disciplinary action against officer Hassett for this incident of brutality and the $70,000 that he cost Buffalo tax payers.

    Address Clinton Street
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 38

    Date Jun 24, 2012
    Time 03:00 AM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Karl B. Schultz , Jason A. Whitenight , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Wilson Morales was shot by Buffalo police officers after a car chase on the city’s East Side. The bullet that struck Morales, then a 17-year-old student at WNY Maritime Charter School, instantly paralyzed him from the chest down.

    Outcome

    Morales, who is still recuperating, faces trial on charges of assaulting a police officer and unlawfully fleeing from a police officer.

    Buffalo’s Common Council authorized one of the largest lawsuit settlements in the city’s history: $4.5 million to Morales. A grand jury cleared Officer Karl B. Schultz and a partner at the time, Jason R. Whitenight, agreeing they fired in self-defense as the teenager backed the van he was driving toward Whitenight at the tail-end of a high-speed chase.

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 331

    Date May 27, 2012
    Time 05:00 AM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Mark P. Andrzejak , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Buffalo police on the lookout for a stolen cruiser around 5 a.m. on a May 5th, 2012 pulled over 25-year-old John Sordetto, who "fit the description." Sordetto was innocent of the car theft, but officer Mark Andrzejak attempted to handcuff him before a scuffle ensued during which Andrzejak fatally shot and killed Sordetto.

    Address Tonawanda Street
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 324

    Date Feb 02, 2012
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Description

    Buffalo Police officers and SWAT moved in around 2 a.m. arrested 10 demonstrators in Niagara Square and evicted the Occupy Buffalo encampment from its downtown location near city hall.

    The city's deadline for the protesters to accept a new agreement to remain in the square until early March expired at midnight. The city only gave the protesters five hours, 7pm‐12am, to discuss the new terms of the agreement. During negotiations, Occupy Buffalo had requested more time. The city refused. Consequently the inability to reach consensus led to their inability to sign the agreement.

    As part of the city's offer to drop disorderly conduct charges against the ten protestors arrested during the overnight eviction from Niagara Square, the protestors agreed not to encamp within a three mile radius of Niagara Square. If they complied, the charges would be dropped.

    Address Niagara Square
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 305

    Date Aug 29, 2010
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers William(Craig) C. Macy Jr , Corey R. Krug , Thomas W. Herbert , Melinda M. Kaska(Jones) , Brian S. Strobele , Joseph E. Paszkiewicz
    Description

    Marcus Worthy was subjected to excessive force, false arrest, malicious prosecution, and abuse of process by Buffalo Police Officers Corey Krug, William Macy, Thomas Herbert, and Joseph Paskiewicz on August 29, 2010. At the time, Worthy, a licensed security guard trainee with a valid pistol permit, was standing outside a residence when the officers arrived in response to an unrelated incident. Without provocation, they tackled, handcuffed, and beat Worthy with a flashlight, causing significant injuries, despite him offering no resistance.

    Following the assault, the officers, joined by Buffalo Police Officer Melinda Jones and Lieutenant Brian Strobele, fabricated felony and misdemeanor charges against Worthy (including menacing a police officer and resisting arrest) to conceal their misconduct.

    Outcome

    The charges filed against Worthy were dismissed by a grand jury.

    A civil complaint filed against the City of Buffalo, Buffalo Police Officers Brian Strobele, Corey Krug, Joseph Paskiewicz, Melinda Jones, Thomas Herbert, and William Macy. A civil case against the City of Buffalo, Corey Krug, and Joseph Hassett was settled for $70,000.

    Corey Krug was charged with violating the civil rights of three men through use of excessive force, one of which included Marcus Worthy. Krug was eventually acquitted on all counts. Krug as well as the other officers have not faced accountability for this incident of brutality.

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 338

    Date Jun 28, 2010
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Ronald T. Ammerman , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Tremel Stone was shot while his back was facing Officer Ron T Ammerman and he was running away. Stone stated that the only reason he ran was because the two officers are well known for planting evidence. Wendy Collier and Ron Ammerman did plant a gun on Stone that was used to charge him with possession of weapon

    Outcome

    With discovery that was provided during a civil suit, it became clear that the officers conspired to plant evidence on Stone. A civil suit against the City of Buffalo and officers involved for damages was settled for $150,000.

    An expert affidavit was submitted by Dannie Sherman, a former law enforcement officer and lead investigator in more than 800 cases. His opinion, with a reasonable degree of certainty, was that the shooting was not justified; there was a cover up with planted evidence with an overall lax review, and the planted evidence was tolerated by the Buffalo Police Department. He states that the level of complaints against Ammerman and Collier is not at all the norm.

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 339

    Date Feb 01, 2010
    Time 02:45 PM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers John C. Garcia , Daniel Derenda
    Description

    Eric "J-J" Ocasio III, a 27 year-old Latino father of 3, in the midst of divorce proceedings, barricaded himself inside his house and drew the Buffalo police SWAT team and negotiators. After almost three hours of talking, two rounds of gunfire, and an officer suffering pellet wounds Ocasio was killed.

    Police said Ocasio did not show up for work at an East Side sheet metal factory and was sending workers suicidal text messages, prompting them to call 911 requesting that police check on his condition. Soon after Central District police responded, there was a report of gunfire, and SWAT and Hostage Management Team members were summoned.

    A reporter with Buffalo News counted 26 bullet holes in a section of aluminum siding just below the windows and many more in the ceiling of the upper front room. Some of the bullets were shot around 12:30PM when Detective John C Garcia entered the backyard behind an armored vehicle and Ocasio fired his shotgun. Garcia suffered pellet wounds from the blast, and SWAT fired at Ocasio as they dragged Garcia out of the yard.

    The second round of police gunfire occured around 2:45PM when Ocasio started to toss his shotgun out the second-floor window barrel first, instead of butt first as police directed him. Ocasio's shotgun was found next to his body.

    During earlier negotiations, Ocasio complied with a police demand that he toss his ammunition out the window, a close friend and witness to the incident said. Police, however, later found more ammunition in the apartment along with a bulletproof vest.

    The friend said Ocasio was attempting to negotiate with police to allow him to smoke a cigarette with his brother before surrendering. The friend explained to Buffalo News reporters that he heard Ocasio say, "I'm going to come down in 17 seconds and put the gun on the porch. All I want is my brother and to smoke a cigarette with him. You can have a SWAT guy with him."

    Results from an autopsy determined Ocasio died from two gunshot wounds.

    Address Trinity Place
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 252

    Date May 30, 2009
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Gregory M. Kwiatkowski , H Mccarthy Gipson , Joseph D. Wendel , Raymond M. Krug
    Description

    Lt. Kwiatkowski arrived at Treehaven Road in Buffalo to respond to a vehicle that had been stopped by the Cheektowaga Police Department (CPD) and that was believed to be involved in an ongoing series of BB gun shootings, including one which occurred earlier that night. Lt. Kwiatkowski was the first BPD officer to arrive at the scene. Other CPD officers were present at the scene when Lt. Kwiatkowski arrived and had already removed the vehicle’s four occupants, who were all between 16 and 18 years old.

    At the time of Lt. Kwiatkowski’s arrival, all of the occupants were compliant and completely under the control of the CPD officers. Upon arriving at the scene, Lt. Kwiatkowski used unlawful and unreasonable force on each of the four occupants. Specifically, Lt. Kwiatkowski admitted to forcibly pushing each of the suspects heads and upper torsos into the vehicle around which they were being detained. He also called the four Black teenagers “savage dogs” and asked, "Do you like shooting at white kids?"

    Outcome

    A federal judge sentenced the former Buffalo Police lieutenant to four months in prison in 2018.

    Address Treehaven Road
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 332

    Date Oct 24, 2008
    Time 02:00 AM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Lamar M. Mcculley
    Description

    Kelvin Rodolph, a 15-year-old Black boy, approached an off-duty Buffalo police officer in front of a convenience store at 2 a.m. and attempted an armed robbery with a BB gun. The officer fired five shots and fatally wounded him.

    Address East Delavan Ave
    Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 340

    Date Jul 09, 2007
    Time 11:40 PM
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers H Mccarthy Gipson
    Description

    Shortly before midnight on July 9th 2007, Deandre L. Baldon, a 17-year-old unarmed Black Burgard High School student, was fatally shot by Buffalo police officer Gerald Smith in Cheektowaga, just east of the Buffalo.

    Based on police account, officer Smith became involved in a car chase of alleged armed occupants that were reported to have fired shots at a man driving another car, injuring his hand and riddling his car with bullet holes. At some point the vehicle involved in the shooting reportedly came to a stop, and three of the occupants fled on foot with officer Smith in pursuit of one of the passengers, later identified as Baldon.

    After a short foot chase, Baldon is said to have stopped, turned and faced the officer. It is not clear whether he was ordered by the police officer to stop and turn around or whether it was a spontaneous act on Baldon's part. As Baldon turned toward the officer, Smith reportedly saw Baldon’s "shiny metal" belt buckle glimmering in the dark, thinking it was a gun. The moment Smith saw the belt buckle, he shot Baldon. Baldon died of a gunshot wound to the chest.

    Outcome

    Buffalo police officer Gerald Smith was cleared by an Erie County grand jury in the fatal shooting of a 17-year-old Buffalo high school student and faced no disciplinary action.

    Address Eggert Rd
    Cheektowaga, NY
     

    Incident 237

    Date Nov 01, 2006
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers Gregory M. Kwiatkowski , Cariol J. Horne , H Mccarthy Gipson
    Description

    In 2006, Officer Cariol Horne intervened to stop a fellow officer, Gregory Kwiatkowski, who was choking Neal Mack, a Black man who was already placed under arrest and handcuffed. Horne was assaulted by the officer during the intervention, and thereafter the Buffalo Police Department punished officer Cariol Horne by terminating her for attempting to stop the assault by her fellow officer upon a citizen —just one year shy of receiving her full pension.

    In October 2020, Buffalo adopted "Cariol's Law," to require police to intervene if a fellow officer uses excessive force. In 2021, a New York court awarded her the pension and back pay she earned. The city has yet to pay Cariol her pension.

    Address Buffalo, NY
     

    Incident 279

    Date Apr 18, 2006
    Department Buffalo Police Department
    Officers H Mccarthy Gipson
    Description

    Background

    Mayor Byron W.  Brown's administration wanted to turn Buffalo's “crime problem” around by trying to replicate former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani's famously tough stance on crime in New York, where crime levels plummeted. This was despite the fact that the “tough on crime” tactics were notorious for racially targeting Black communities and crime levels were dropping before Giuliani took office.

    Brown declared what he called a "zero-tolerance" policy on so-called "quality-of-life" crimes in an effort to curb petty crime.

    Buffalo Police Chief H. McCarthy Gipson announced when he was appointed to his position in February 2006, ”we're going to have to be mobile, agile and slightly hostile in trying to get the job of policing done in the City of Buffalo.”

    The several days prior to the events detailed below, the Erie County Executive at the time, Joel Giambra, publicly came out against the Drug War. Giambra held a press conference with members of Law Enforcement Against Prohibition, a group of ex-cops and prosecutors advocating the decriminalization or legalization of drugs.

    The Raids

    From April 18th to April 20th, 2006, 38 Buffalo homes were invaded by no-knock SWAT raids in "Operation Shock and Awe," a phrase, borrowed from the US military to describe its strategy in the early days of the Iraq War. The war on drug raids were conducted under the direction of then Buffalo Police Commissioner H. McCarthy Gipson over a three day period and resulted in the arrest of approximately 78 people.

    The department even invited a couple of reporters from the Buffalo News(BN) to cover the invasion, like embedded war correspondents. "We are declaring war on street-level drug dealing," Gipson told two reporters from the BN, during one of the raids.

    Scores of police officers dressed in military battle gear conducted the no-knock SWAT raids deploying diversionary grenades, broke down doors with battering rams, and stormed residences with automatic assault rifles ablaze traumatizing entire communities while they were going about their daily lives. Accounts of the raids detail a 1-year-old being present while shotgun blasts rang out and their three dogs were murdered in front of their eyes,

    Gipson declared victory, boasting of the department’s haul: six pounds of marijuana, seven ounces of crack cocaine, and five guns. 

    Outcome

    A month after the raids occurred, an analysis conducted by the Buffalo News found that of the 78 Buffalo residents who were originally detained during the raids, only 20 faced a felony charge. Sixteen Buffalo residents were immediately released because the judge found there wasn't enough evidence to support legally sound charges. At least 36 of those arrested were out of jail within 24 hours of being arrested.

    The original six pounds of marijuana police claimed to have found was actually four pounds, thirteen ounces. Three and a half pounds of that came by way of an unrelated traffic stop on the same day that raids had taken place and had nothing to do with the raids. They found all of five guns. 

    City leaders were furious, not because city police had just terrorized innocent people with fruitless SWAT raids, but because they believed so many petty offenders were let off. City officials demanded tougher drug laws.

    Commissioner Gipson meet with City Court judges, following the charge dismissals, to try and encourage them to increase bail for people charged with drug dealing. However, City Court judges said they simply didn't have the discretion to impose harsh sentences just because the mayor ordered a crackdown on drugs. Council Member Dominic Bonifacio Jr. of Niagara District said that the dismissals were, "a slap in the face to our good men in blue" and claimed that they proved the “revolving door in the court system.”

    Judge Thomas P. Franczyk, who presided over the majority of cases from the raids, said he found problems with police paperwork that they don’t pass legal muster. "It still has to pass the test of legal sufficiency," Franczyk said. "The law is the law, and the facts are the facts," he said. "In some cases, the accusatory paperwork is not alleging sufficient facts to support the defendant's knowing and unlawful possession of the drugs . . . It's not enough to say they were there when the drugs were found somewhere in the house."

    Franczyk sent a letter to Commissioner Gipson, urging him to have his officers meet with the members of the District Attorney's office to cut down on paperwork errors and properly document evidence.

    "What we learned was we need to be more specific about who possesses what," conceded Chief of Detectives Dennis Richards, who said he and other police brass recently sat down with narcotics detectives to make sure they write up their paperwork correctly after realizing that police actually have to have evidence of a crime for an arrest to have legal standing.

    Department and city officials started to discuss sending narcotics cops and SWAT teams out with housing inspectors and the county Health Department to “clean up” suspected crack houses without the Fourth Amendment warrant requirements. The inspectors' presence would enable police to get inside the home without the legal hurdle of procuring a search warrant, intentionally circumventing constitutionally protected right to no unlawful search and seizures. And police talked about looking into working with federal housing officials to seize problem drug houses.

    Shock and Awe "is just the beginning," said Richards, the chief of detectives.  "If you're dealing drugs in Buffalo, basically, you're going to be dealing with the Police Department. There will certainly be more raids in the future," Richards said. "You can count on that . . . We're looking at small-scale, large-scale, street-level. Nice quiet streets marred by one drug house as well as entire streets written off as drug house streets. So we're looking at top to bottom."

    Gipson said arresting dealers repeatedly may be the only way to get the message through, comparing it to the aggressive, long-term approach to treating drug abusers, who often try to quit multiple times before having success.  "Our effectiveness comes in trying to keep them off kilter .  .  .  Keep them wondering if we're coming today or not coming."

    Buffalo Police and city leadership took several steps beyond the raids in the war on drugs. The Police Department rearranged its squads to add three more sergeants and eight detectives to its Narcotics Unit, which operated day and night, instead of just at night. The city also reintroduced "Operation Clean Sweep," in which a team of law enforcement, city inspectors and other city workers descend on a block identified as having crime and blight problems. 

    As for the Brown Administration's decision to replicate the Giuliani “tough on crime” strategy, well Rudy Giuliani’s personal reputation in tatters but so is the reputation of the tough-on-crime policing system he supervised as mayor of NYC in the 90s. There have now been 18 overturned convictions from that era based on the testimony of a single corrupt NYPD detective, Lou Scarcella.

    Address Buffalo, NY